Mith, I do think box steel would be easier to build with.
I have plans for a larger more powerful catapult that I hope to build this summer. I'm looking at an 8' throwing arm and think a 2" x 3" box steel arm would be just the ticket. Honestly I did not study the plans in great detail for the catapult I posted in the PDF section of the Gallery. I looked them over, they seemed reasonable, but as I have a more complete CAD based set of plans for my own use, I have considered and resolved to use a steel arm. Also I'll be using a steel barstock axle. I'm not sure if I will go so far as to use ball bearings to reduce friction, but I might! I do know that I will make mine on some sort of movable base, possibly a trailer/wagon?
I have plans for a larger more powerful catapult that I hope to build this summer. I'm looking at an 8' throwing arm and think a 2" x 3" box steel arm would be just the ticket. Honestly I did not study the plans in great detail for the catapult I posted in the PDF section of the Gallery. I looked them over, they seemed reasonable, but as I have a more complete CAD based set of plans for my own use, I have considered and resolved to use a steel arm. Also I'll be using a steel barstock axle. I'm not sure if I will go so far as to use ball bearings to reduce friction, but I might! I do know that I will make mine on some sort of movable base, possibly a trailer/wagon?